The talent problem in finance isn’t hiring. It’s what happens after parental leave

Finance, accounting, and insurance are built on precision.

Accuracy.
Judgement.
Performance under pressure.

These are industries where people are expected to operate at a consistently high level — often with little room for error.

And for the most part, that works.

Until something changes.


The moment that breaks the model

Each year, highly capable professionals step away from these roles for parental leave.

Senior analysts.
Managers.
Directors.

People who have spent years building expertise in complex, high-responsibility environments.

And when they return, the expectation is simple:

 Pick up where you left off.

But the reality is far more complex.


What’s actually changed

When someone returns to work after having a child, three things have shifted — whether the organisation recognises it or not:

1. Their capacity
They’re operating with significantly higher cognitive load outside of work.

2. Their relationship to work
Priorities, boundaries, and tolerance for pressure often evolve.

3. Their internal confidence
Even highly capable individuals can experience a temporary dip — particularly in high-stakes environments.


And what hasn’t changed

The role.

The expectations.

The pace.

The pressure to perform quickly and visibly.


Why this is a problem in these industries

In finance, accounting, and insurance, performance is often:

  • Immediate
  • Measurable
  • Visible

There’s little space for:

  • Slower ramp-up
  • Rebuilding confidence
  • Adjusting to new capacity

So what happens?

Returners often feel:

  • Behind
  • Exposed
  • Under pressure to prove themselves quickly

How it shows up (and gets misread)

From a leadership perspective, this can look like:

  • Reduced confidence in decision-making
  • Hesitation or slower output
  • Less visibility or participation

And it’s often interpreted as:

 A drop in capability
 A loss of ambition

When in reality, it’s neither.

It’s a transition that hasn’t been supported.


The cost to the business

This is where it becomes commercially critical.

Because the outcome isn’t always immediate exit.

It’s often more subtle:

  • Stepping back from promotion pathways
  • Moving into lower-responsibility roles
  • Quiet disengagement
  • Leaving within 6–18 months

And in industries where:

  • Talent is expensive to replace
  • Expertise takes years to build
  • Leadership pipelines are already fragile

That’s a significant loss.


Why current approaches aren’t working

Most organisations in these sectors have:

  • Strong maternity policies
  • Flexible working options
  • Increasing focus on diversity

But they’re still missing the key moment:

👉 The transition back into work

Because the assumption remains:

If someone is back, they’re ready.


A different way to think about it

In these industries, risk is managed everywhere:

  • Financial risk
  • Operational risk
  • Regulatory risk

But there’s a critical risk that’s rarely addressed:

Transition risk

The risk that highly capable people underperform or exit — not because they can’t do the job, but because the transition back hasn’t been managed.


What changes when this is supported properly

When organisations take this moment seriously:

  • Confidence rebuilds faster
  • Performance stabilises sooner
  • Retention improves — particularly at senior levels
  • Leadership pipelines strengthen

Because people aren’t forced to choose between:
 staying and struggling
 or leaving altogether


The opportunity

Finance, accounting, and insurance don’t have a talent problem.

They have a transition problem.

And the organisations that recognise that — and design for it — will have a clear advantage.

Not just in retention.

But in performance.


Because the issue isn’t whether people can do the job.

It’s whether they’re being supported to step back into it in a way that actually works.


If you’re seeing a drop-off in confidence, performance, or retention after parental leave — it’s worth looking at how that transition is being handled.

That’s exactly the space I work in: helping organisations retain experienced talent by supporting the moment they’re most likely to lose it.

I share more about this on LinkedIn

you can book a call if you want to talk it through